Reengineering Health Care

Reengineering Health Care essay assignment

Reengineering Health Care essay assignment

Introduction

Decisions based on ethical and legal principles are common in a person’s life. Choices such as whether to indulge in gossip (breaching confidentiality) or driving too fast on the highway are examples of these decisions. Making good ethical and legal decisions in nursing management or leadership practice requires understanding of the underlying principles and incorporating that knowledge into the decision-making process.

Get solution to your nursing paper : Reengineering Health Care

Ethical Decision-Making

Ethical decision-making is similar to other decision-making processes in that it requires the manager to gather information, identify the problem, generate alternatives, or select an alternative to implement, and evaluate the results. The difference in ethical decision-making depends on the identification of the ethical principles that guide the selection and expectations of the outcome.

The principles underlying ethical decision-making include concepts that are familiar to practicing nurses. Is it best for the nurse to use specialized knowledge to make decisions for a patient (paternalism) or to support patients in making their own decisions (autonomy)? Are there circumstances in which the need to benefit the majority of staff (utility) outweighs the need to treat everyone fairly (justice)? Is telling a white lie (violating the principle of truth-telling) justified when it is believed that the withholding of the truth will benefit the recipient (beneficence)? These are the competing obligations that create ethical dilemmas. Ethical decision-making requires the identification of competing principles as a part of describing the problem.

Get solution to your nursing paper : Reengineering Health Care

Ethical frameworks and professional codes of ethics exist to assist the manager in ethical decision-making. Both frameworks and codes provide guidance in valuing one principle above another, but do not directly provide the solution. There are several ethical frameworks. Two commonly used frameworks are utilitarian-based and rights-based. A utilitarian framework advocates selecting an alternative that will result in the greatest good for the greatest number of people, focusing on the projected outcome. An example of using a utilitarian framework is the isolation of a patient with a communicable disease. Although this isolation infringes on the person’s autonomy, the common good (utility) of not spreading the disease is served. A rights-based framework focuses on the process of decision-making and utilization of identified rights or entitlements. This type of framework is evident in The Bill of Rights for Registered Nurses (The American Nurses Association, n.d.).

Professional codes of ethics have been published by several professional nursing organizations. These codes generally support the principles of autonomy, justice, and beneficence, but they also acknowledge that there are times when competing obligations may require the nurse to select alternatives based on other principles.

Ethical decision-making is also unique in that it often entails choosing among less than desirable alternatives. The outcome of the decision may not be judged as good but as better than other outcomes. When evaluating the outcome of ethical decision-making, reviewing the process used to make the decision is as important as the result (Marquis and Huston, 2009).

Legal Environment in Nursing Management

Ethical frameworks and codes of ethics provide guidance for decision-making, but are not required. Laws are written to support the values and ethics of society, requiring citizens to act in a certain manner or face the consequences in a court of law. There are wide ranges of laws that affect the practice of a nurse manager. Legislation directly affects both patient care and professional relationships with employees.

Get solution to your nursing paper : Reengineering Health Care

Patient care related legislation primarily supports patient autonomy. Laws exist to require informed consent prior to performing a procedure on a patient. This allows patients to make informed choices regarding their health care. Ignoring informed consent can lead to charges of assault and battery (causing the patient to feel threatened or touching the patient who has not consented). The unwarranted use of restraints can constitute false imprisonment. The nurse manager is responsible for ensuring that organizational policies provide guidance to staff in avoiding these legal issues. The HIPAA Standards for Privacy of Individually Identifiable Health Information Act supports patient confidentiality by regulating how and when an individual’s information may be shared (U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, 2007).

Legislation that affects employee relations covers general topics such as discrimination and fair labor laws. In general, anti-discrimination laws require that all employees be treated fairly. The requirement that employees speak English only in the workplace is an example of a potential source of national discrimination (Lewis, 2004). Policies must be carefully written to meet legal requirements while allowing the organization to fulfill its mission. It is fundamental to seek legal advice when addressing sensitive policy issues.

Particular to the nurse manager are laws that relate to the professional scope of practice for licensed and unlicensed health care workers. Nurses in management positions are responsible for assuring that employees maintain required professional licensure, practice within their scope, and maintain competence in their practice. Providing feedback and disciplinary measures for staff that are violating these practices are an important part of the management role (Marquis and Huston, 2009). Appropriate delegation of duties falls within this realm as well; staff must not be required to practice outside their scope or provide care in which they are not competent.

Keeping abreast of the legal environment is imperative for the nurse manager. Collaboration with human resources and legal professionals will assist the manager in maintaining compliance with current laws.

Get solution to your nursing paper : Reengineering Health Care

Advocating for Patients and Staff

Nurses in management and leadership positions frequently find themselves in the role of advocate for both patients and staff. Advocacy is a process used to facilitate growth in others. Common methods of advocacy are: 1) providing others with information that empowers them to make their own decisions, and 2) acting on behalf of others who do not have the ability or power to advocate for themselves. Care must be taken to ensure that advocacy remains focused on supporting decision-making, rather than making decisions for others.

The nurse manager advocates for patients by developing a unit culture that promotes respect for patients and their ability to make decisions, even if those decisions are different from the ones the staff members would make. Patient education is one method of empowering patients; the manager ensures that both the materials and time are available for this nursing function. The manager can also listen to staff as they converse about patients and provide feedback on instances of respectful or disrespectful conversations.

Staff concerns may also require the nurse manager to act as an advocate within the organization. Issues arising from staffing levels, care delivery, and the need for professional development may not be as highly valued by the organization. The nurse manager, using the power of the position, can often be more effective than individual staff members in fulfilling the advocacy role.

Beyond the organization, there are numerous initiatives that benefit from nurse advocacy. Patient safety and access to care are among these initiatives. The role of the individual nurse is important; however, Welchman and Griener (2005) make a case for greater involvement of professional organizations in the advocacy role. They argue that since professional organizations have greater power to effect change than individual nurses, that advocacy should be a larger part of their mission.

The most important and most difficult skill for a leader is the ability to listen. Leaders must listen to the sounds of change. Leaders must help people work through the grieving process and conflicts experienced during time of change. Because the pace of change in health care is so rapid, leaders must be prepared to deal with the chaos and uncertainty through calm communication. The focus for this week will be on change management, problem solving, conflict resolution, and communication methodologies for dealing with crises.

Get solution to your nursing paper : Reengineering Health Care

Change Management

In the good old days, change came slowly and was predictable. Today, change happens so quickly that it is sometimes difficult to realize when one change has been completed and another change has begun. Often, more than one change is happening at the same time, and people are adapting to multiple changes at once. One of the contributing factors to this rapid change is the availability of information.

In the 20th century, knowledge was treated as a possession. One had knowledge or gained knowledge. The process of learning was essentially a process of stuffing facts into one’s head. As a result of this process, the knowledgeable person possessed knowledge and could draw from it when necessary. Our modern existence has led us to view knowledge as a utility. Because so much information is available, no one could ever have sufficient capacity to acquire all the knowledge he or she will need. Thus, the focus has shifted from possession to access (Porter-O’Grady and Malloch, 2002, p. 42).

The only thing constant in this world is change. Longstanding contracts are being broken. Employment for life and even employer loyalty are outdated concepts, meaning that organizations will change. If organizations are to survive, adaptation to change is essential. The key to comfort in change is to try out the new before giving up the old by getting those affected by the change involved. Wilson and Porter-O’Grady (1999) describe the best scenario as “solid growth and partial stability” (p. 275). Leaders have the difficult task of helping others to move towards change while tempering the movement so that it does not move too fast. Managing change is really about helping people maintain or enhance their self-esteem through the period of transition.

So, how should change be managed? Following these steps will help a leader with transitioning to the next level of understanding:

1.Analyze the need for change.

2.Create a shared vision and common direction.

3.Separate from the past.

4.Create a sense of urgency.

5.Support a strong leader role.

6.Develop an implementation plan.

7.Develop structures that support the change.

8.Communicate, involve people, and be honest.

9.Reinforce the change.

10.The hardest phase of change is maintenance. Adult learners need constant reinforcement until the change becomes a habit.

Conflict Resolution

Conflict is often perceived in a negative manner, yet it is a normal and essential component to human interaction. Intelligent leaders realize that conflict can cause change and that this change may be a positive move for an organization. When conflict is present, differing views emerge from stakeholders. The presence of these views forces out-of-the-box discussions and dialogue. “The truth is that everyone who comes together brings with him or her insights, perspectives, views, experiences, and life applications that are specific and unique to the individual participant” (Wilson and Porter-O’Grady, 1999, p. 417). Recognizing the strength in diversity and having the insight necessary to manage conflict is a critical skill for health care leaders.

Get solution to your nursing paper : Reengineering Health Care

Conflict resolution is made up of the processes by which the parties involved achieve an agreement where all participants have an advantage. The purpose of the leader in conflict is to facilitate or mediate and assist the parties to a resolution of the issue through common ground. Some of the questions the leader might ask include:

1.What is the key issue in the conflict?

2.At what point did the conflict emerge?

3.What are the individual views of each stakeholder?

4.What are the barriers to resolution?

5.How does each participant envision the final outcome?

An important mission for the leader is to make sure that each participant understands the issues of the other person, that all perceptions are clarified, and that there is a common understanding for an outcome.

Communicating During Crisis

Conflict is often precipitated by a surprise crisis which is usually viewed as negative and causes distorted perceptions and disruptions. is a key factor in response to any crisis. Effective communication helps to provide direction and disseminate information while maintaining credibility.

Before a crisis occurs, leadership should be briefed on the defined communication chain and logistical details. Brainstorming can be a proactive action to crisis. The plan should include information such as names, phone numbers, availability, inventory, availability of equipment, parking, staff, and anticipated written material for media.

During a crisis, leaders should debrief frequently. Questions that should be answered include:

1.Who are the stakeholders?

2.How, when, and where did the problem begin?

3.What is happening now?

4.What are the possible scenarios through which the situation will play out?

5.What are the legal and ethical ramifications?

6.Has this happened before? If so, how was it handled?

Coordinating communication is imperative to the stability of the people within the organization. Internal and external audiences will be present and might include the media, family members, visitors, patients, and employees. Leaders should strive to communicate only the facts, deal with rumors swiftly, and document crises in writing so that there will be an inventory and record of the event. When a crisis is over, a debriefing should help identify areas of strength, areas of weakness, and a follow-up plan.

Conclusion

Ethics and legal principles provide the foundation for the practice of management in nursing and the role of advocacy. Historically and currently, many issues in health care, such as the movement to improve patient safety, have both ethical and legal implications. The American Nurses Association (ANA) Code of Ethics (2005) requires nurses to be advocates for their patients, ensuring that patients have a voice in their care, and that their decisions are respected. Additionally, nurse managers must ensure that staff members have a voice in the workplace that empowers them to advocate for patients and for themselves.

Conflict and change are inevitable. Good leaders are always on the edge of chaos, looking over the horizon, looking just beyond the precipice, and they are able to read, interpret, and express what they discern when situations arise. Their real gift is their ability to walk back to where those they lead are living and translate what they have seen into a language that has force and meaning for those who can hear it. They then have the job of getting behind the staff and pushing them into their own definition of the emerging reality, allowing the staff to own what they see and act on it in a responsive and viable way (Porter-O’Grady and Malloch, 2002, p. 36). Leadership’s role is to tame the change, control the conflict, and manage the communication.

References

American Nursing Association. (2005). Code of ethics for nurses.

Lewis, J. (2004). English-only policies require business necessity and proper procedures. Workplace Resource Center.

Marquis, B. L., & Huston, C. J. (2009). Leadership roles and management functions in nursing: Theory and application (6th ed.). Philadelphia, PA: Lippincott, Williams & Wilkins.

Porter-O’Grady, T., & Malloch, K. (2002). Quantum leadership: A textbook of new leadership. Sudbury, MA: Jones & Bartlett Learning.

U.S. Department of Health and Human Services. (2007). About the privacy rule FAQs. Retrieved July 22, 2005, from http://www.hhs.gov/hipaafaq/about/index.html

Welchman, J., & Griener, G. G. (2005). Patient advocacy and professional associations: Individual and collective responsibilities. Nursing Ethics, 12(3), 296-304.

Wilson, C. K., & Porter-O’Grady, T. (1999). Leading the revolution in health care: Advancing systems, igniting performance(2nd ed.). Gaithersburg, MD: Aspen Publishers.

Discussion 1

How does the nurse manager or leader play a role in the reengineering of health care?

Discussion 2

Continuous quality improvement (CQI) is the responsibility of all nurses and is vital when addressing the challenges of the health care industry. Provide an example of how you would apply CQI in your current or past position.